What to do when your yarn doesn’t play ball with your chosen pattern? Do you fix your project or just frog your knitting and repurpose the yarn for a different design?
I shared last time that the most exciting project I was working on was the Calm Down Cardigan by Lily Kate France. Since that post, I made lots of progress and finished knitting the whole body. While I was knitting, I had a niggling feeling that my yarn choice was hindering the way the finished sweater was supposed to look. But I kept going forward following the pattern instructions and even completed a lengthy tubular bind-off.
I didn’t actively measure my progress along the way and things “seemed” to be fine. But then once the body was done, I tried it on and the half-finished cardigan almost visibly lengthened in front of my eyes! Gah!!
I thought the armholes were quite deep on this pattern so adding a sleeve would tighten things up. Nope, it’s still too long. I had forgotten to consider that this beautiful, soft yarn is comprised of 70% alpaca fiber! Alpaca, while it is so soft and dreamy, doesn’t have great memory and spring, unlike pure wool. No wonder my sweater was growing in length as the weight of the fabric increased.
I could choose to rip out a bit of the sweater and shorten the body length. However, is there any guarantee that the fabric won’t continue to stretch out with wear? Unfortunately, I will have to frog this project and use the beautiful yarn for a different design. I still want to knit the Calm Down Cardigan because this pattern is very well written and has so many great details. However, I will choose my yarn very thoughtfully next time đ
I had to remind myself that when a pattern-yarn combination isn’t the best match, I need to be fearless and frog my knitting. I will be much happier to restart than have a sweater sit unworn and unloved in my closet.